Reviewing IRA Section 45 Credits Under a Trump Administration
Building a business model for the next four years and beyond..
The Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) introduced a range of tax incentives under Section 45 to promote clean energy development, reduce greenhouse gas emissions, and stimulate economic growth. These credits have been instrumental in reshaping the energy landscape in the United States. However, a Trump administration—known for prioritizing traditional energy sources like coal and oil—might bring a shift in policy focus, potentially altering the effectiveness and implementation of these credits. Below is a comprehensive review of the key IRA 45 credits and their possible trajectories under such an administration.
1. Production Tax Credit (PTC) for Renewable Energy
The Section 45 Production Tax Credit incentivizes the production of electricity from renewable sources, such as wind, solar, and geothermal. It offers a per-kilowatt-hour (kWh) credit for the first ten years of a facility’s operation.
Potential Impact Under a Trump Administration:
Curtailment of Wind Energy Credits: The Trump administration’s historical skepticism toward wind energy could result in reduced funding or stricter eligibility criteria for wind PTCs.
Shift to Natural Gas: There may be an emphasis on natural gas as a "cleaner" fossil fuel alternative, reducing the relative competitiveness of renewables.
2. Carbon Capture and Sequestration (CCS) Credit
Section 45Q provides a credit for the capture and storage of carbon dioxide (CO2). This incentive has gained bipartisan support due to its application across fossil fuel and industrial sectors.
Potential Impact Under a Trump Administration:
Increased Support for CCS: Given its alignment with continued fossil fuel use, CCS credits might see expanded support. This could benefit coal and natural gas plants seeking to reduce emissions without shutting down operations.
Focus on Enhanced Oil Recovery (EOR): The administration may prioritize CCS projects linked to EOR, a process that uses captured CO2 to extract more oil from existing fields.
3. Clean Hydrogen Production Credit
The IRA introduced a credit for clean hydrogen production, with higher incentives for facilities achieving low carbon intensity.
Potential Impact Under a Trump Administration:
Reduced Emphasis on Green Hydrogen: Green hydrogen projects reliant on renewable energy might face challenges if the administration scales back renewable energy incentives.
Blue Hydrogen Favoritism: Hydrogen produced from natural gas with CCS (blue hydrogen) could receive greater support due to its compatibility with existing fossil fuel infrastructure.
4. Renewable Natural Gas (RNG) and Biogas Credits
Section 45 credits also apply to renewable natural gas and biogas projects, promoting the conversion of organic waste into usable energy.
Potential Impact Under a Trump Administration:
Moderate Continuation: Given the waste management and energy security benefits of RNG, these credits might remain largely intact. However, funding levels could stagnate compared to the IRA’s more aggressive implementation.
5. Advanced Manufacturing Production Credit
This credit supports the domestic production of clean energy components, such as solar panels, wind turbines, and battery cells.
Potential Impact Under a Trump Administration:
Reduced Focus on Domestic Manufacturing: If the administration prioritizes deregulation and international trade, domestic manufacturing incentives could take a back seat, making the U.S. less competitive in the global clean energy supply chain.
Support for Traditional Energy Equipment: The focus could shift toward equipment used in traditional energy sectors, potentially reducing support for clean energy technologies.
6. Energy Storage Tax Credits
The IRA extends Section 45 credits to standalone energy storage projects, critical for grid stability and renewable energy integration.
Potential Impact Under a Trump Administration:
Scaling Back of Storage Incentives: Energy storage, particularly when paired with renewables, may face funding cuts or reduced emphasis.
Focus on Fossil Fuel Resilience: Support could pivot toward technologies that enhance the resilience of fossil fuel-based grids.
7. Sustainable Aviation Fuel (SAF) Credit
Section 45Z introduces a tax credit for Sustainable Aviation Fuel (SAF), aiming to reduce the carbon footprint of air travel. The credit amount depends on the lifecycle greenhouse gas emissions reduction achieved by the SAF compared to conventional jet fuel.
Potential Impact Under a Trump Administration:
Focus on Biofuels with Fossil Links: SAF derived from feedstocks compatible with existing fossil fuel infrastructure might receive support, but stricter requirements for lifecycle emissions could be deprioritized.
Reduced Emphasis on Advanced SAF: Technologies that rely on innovative or renewable feedstocks might face funding challenges if the administration shifts focus away from climate-centered aviation goals.
Broader Implications
Under a Trump administration, the overarching approach to Section 45 credits could include:
Regulatory Rollbacks: Deregulation of energy markets could undermine the competitiveness of renewable energy projects.
Reduced Climate Ambitions: A focus on economic growth through traditional energy sources might deprioritize emissions reductions, affecting the adoption of low-carbon technologies.
Shift Toward Energy Independence: While clean energy may remain a component of energy policy, the administration’s focus could lean heavily toward domestic fossil fuel production.
Conclusion
The future of IRA Section 45 credits under a Trump administration would likely depend on a delicate balance between economic, environmental, and political priorities. While some credits—like those for CCS, RNG, and SAF—may align with the administration’s energy strategy, others, particularly those heavily tied to renewables, could face significant challenges. Stakeholders in the energy sector must prepare for potential policy shifts by diversifying investments and advocating for bipartisan solutions that maintain the momentum toward a cleaner, more sustainable energy future.